Tattoos in Japan: Taboo or Not?
Before going to Japan, everyone gave me the exact same warning: it’s going to be difficult there with your tattoos. This was said to me from both people who lived there and those who had never visited the country. You’ll have to cover them up! You won’t be able to go to such and such with them! People will think you’re a criminal! It seems to be a “fact” that most people “know”. People really do believe that tattoos in Japan are not appreciated. But how much truth is there to it, and how much is purely overblown stigma?
A Brief History
The contrasting relationship between the Japanese and tattoos is almost as old as time itself. Its known that even during the Jomon era over 16,000 years ago, much like the culture of the maori people, tattoos were considered highly sacred. Their prevalence found on recovered figures leads historians to believe they were a vital part of tribal culture, possibly even a rite-of-passage. They also identified tribal members as well as signifying their social status and prestige. However, by the Edo period (1603-1868) this tradition had disappeared just as much as the tribal cultures themselves.
It’s during this period in history where tattoos would take a turn for the worst in the eyes of the Japanese. Tattoos (or irezumi-kei) henceforth were used to mark out criminals. Often markings were placed on their foreheads or arms; somewhere not easily hidden. These people would face the punishment of forever being outcasts of society with their distinguishable symbols. This form of branding discouraged would-be felons that feared such social disapproval as well as having to withstand the intense pain of receiving one.
Eventually the practice was dropped, however by then the stigma of tattoos had been firmly imprinted in the minds of Japanese citizens. Before the tradition had come to an end, one group of individuals in Japanese society had already started to adopt the practice into their own culture.
For decades, one class of Japanese citizens has become associated with visible tattoos more than anyone else becoming synonymous with the artistic format. They are of course the notorious Japanese gangsters, or as the majourity of the world know them as; the yakuza.
The yakuza’s adoption of this culture began as a protest and uprising to the unusually cruel form of criminal branding. This quickly transformed into a mark of pride and a definitive expression of their rebelliousness against society. The earliest precursors of the yakuza would incorporate other artistic works into the tattoos they had already been branded with. Soon, just like the tribal tattoos of old, they became a symbol of status within the early forming organizations.
This marked the beginning of a new tradition amongst yakuza members as modifying their bodies with varying symbolic art became almost a rite-of-passage. They would regularly undergo the very painful process of irezumi; a specific method of hand-poked tattoos. The pain itself was a vital step in the process, being an opportunity for prospective gang members to demonstrate their courage and perseverance in the face of adversity. They’re both a symbolic representation of themselves as well as their organization. Even the cost of the tattoos themselves are a symbol of status amongst the different factions. Being able to afford to cover their entire bodies is a sign of their financial success.
However, unlike the crips and bloods on the streets of L.A. with tear-drops on their cheeks and sub-machine guns on their necks, Japanese yakuza members prefer a degree of discretion. Due to the undeniable link between criminality and tattoos, their artworks are traditionally covered when completely clothed i.e. avoiding the face and hands. Many designs even leave a strip of clean skin running down the centre of their torso to allow them to unbuttoned their shirts without causing alarm.
21st Century Reality
Fast forward to the 21st century, is this really still the case? I was told endlessly that I’d have to cover them up, that people will be offended by the sight of them. Do tattoos in Japan still mark you out as a criminal, a lesser member of society? The simple answer is – not really. Though this a quite accepted fact, in reality (outside of rare cases) it’s not true.
People aren’t appalled or cross the street as they see a tattooed individual approaching. On the contrary, during my time there on multiple occasions I had people approaching me to compliment my obvious Japanese designs. Frankly what you might over-hear or read online is very much blown out of proportion. It’s made out that you must always be aware of showing your artwork in public when in-fact you don’t. On a daily basis in the country, there are practically no negative reactions to tattoos (apart from one industry, we’ll get to that shortly).
If there is a remaining stigma amongst the public, then it’s simply nothing more than an old-fashioned mind set. Sure, a 75-year old grandma might very well associate your ink covered arms with the criminal underworld. However, a 21-year old student or club goer doesn’t give the slightest shit. Quite the opposite in-fact, the young folk are as fascinated with them just as much as the youth of any other nation! It’s not even that unusual to see the odd Japanese citizen that has one themselves. Not as often as back in the West of course, but certainly not rare.
The Remaining Stigma
Now, I would be lying if I said that modern life in Japan is completely free from stigma towards tattoos, though its not as bad as it’s made out to be. Practically in every public place displaying your tattoos is not a problem. That includes restaurants, bars, parks, beaches, its all fair game. That being said, one particular type of establishment is an exception, and quite a significant one when it comes to tourists in Japan; onsens.
Onsens are Japanese hot-springs. Found throughout the country and incredibly popular with both locals and visitors alike, and for good reason. However, these seem to be one of the few places where real stigma towards tattoos still exist.
It’s of varying levels. The majority of establish outright deny entry to anyone (foreign or otherwise) who have any sort of tattoos. Others allow entry if the tattoos are small, discrete or easily hidden by use of a towel. Others will require you to reserve a private booth (at extra cost) to keep you hidden from public eyes. Only a very select few will allow use of their public pools with an open mind to tattoos.
In-fact back in 2015 the Japanese Tourism Agency underwent a survey of over 3800 ryokans (traditional inns that include an onsen) about their policies towards tattoos. 56% outright refuse tattooed guests with only 31% allowing them without any restrictions. This prejudice extends to similar industries such as swimming pools, bath houses and gyms. Essentially those kind of leisure establishments where more flesh is usually on show.
Though visiting one is not impossible, it just causes a bit of a hassle. If you’re like me, a simple plaster or bandage can’t hide my extensive tattoos, unless I wanted to appear to wear a full-body cast. In this case you just have to research beforehand where will allow them. These days as its such a reoccurring problem places will usually state their policies on their website quite clearly. There are even specific websites for tattooed folk to find acceptable venues, such as Tattoo Spot.
Count yourself lucky, as in years past it wasn’t this simple. You would have had to go to an onsen exclusively used by the yakuza if you wanted to try one. However, with the changing modern times and tattoos becoming more prevalent, establishments have increasing pressure to start changing their policies. Tourist cash is a very important source of income after all, and almost every visitor to Japan will want to experience an onsen. Thus the acceptence of tattoos has began to increase little by little.
A Governmental Mindset
It seems some members of the government still uphold the antiquated mindset towards tattoos. You might notice that you spot very few tattoo parlours during your time in the country. This is down in no small part to what the governmental believe receiving a tattoo is.
Take the city of Osaka as an example. They consider the process of giving a tattoo to be a medical procedure, as it involves needles piercing the skin. Thus, tattoo artist must qualify to be medical doctors before they can give a tattoo. Imagine having to go through a 4-5 year medical course just to turn around and say you want to be a tattoo artist, absurd!
Of course this hasn’t stopped everyone. Either way most traditional tattoo artist whose clientele include hardened Yakuza members only work on a word-of-mouth basis.
Don’t Believe the Hype
Again, the majourity of chatter on the topic is overblown and nothing more than rumour snowballing. Nothing proved this more than at my time in a Buddhist temple just outside of Nagoya. It was another type of establishment where I was told I should cover my tattoos out of respect. Of course that makes sense. Having a half-naked woman or a grim reaper displayed across your arms might not be appreciated in a place of worship.
I kept that in mind and fastidiously ensured my tattoos were covered for the first few days, not wishing to offend the resident monk or his family. That was until a particular day I took off my jacket and had the entire family look in open-eyed fascination at my arm. They began asking endless questions about my Japanese style sleeve before the Buddhist monks daughter rolled up her shirt to reveal she had one of her own!
A Foreign Influence
In the last year, two enormous events will have assisted in forcing Japan to reconsider its stance. Back in October the country played host to the Rugby World Cup, and this summer Tokyo will host the Summer Olympics. Two events which brings with it an enormous influx of foreign visitors from across the globe. They bring with them a number of different cultures and mindsets, which Japan must be welcoming and open-minded towards. One of these is the tattoo culture.
We in the west have long come to terms with the fact that tattoos are just a normal part of life. Its not a shocking revelation to posses one and neither does it have anything to do with the character of the individual. Us foreigners have in a way helped to steer the outlook of tattoos away from criminality. Take me for example, would the Japanese really believe “Oh shit, that white boy’s in the Yakuza!”?
This has actually risen quite an important ethical quandary. A debate was sparked back in 2013 as a Maori academic visiting the country was denied entry to an onsen because of the traditional tribal tattoo she had on her face. Japan is a nation full of the most respectable and polite individuals you’ll ever meet. However the situation shone light on the fact that these policies appear to be discriminatory to cultures different to theirs.
If cultural differences isn’t enough to bring a change, perhaps financial incentives will. An enormous influx of Westerners comes with it an ever bigger influx of money. The Japanese economy doesn’t want to miss out on that juicy tourist cash because of an antiquated and inaccurate stigma.
Is It Really Different To Anywhere Else
Following my time in Japan and reading a number of articles on the subject, I couldn’t help but feel a sense of fear mongering. Apart from the onsens and similar establishments as mentioned previously, there’s practically zero direct prejudice to tattoos.
Yes, some people will hate the sight of them, possibly be offended. Some people will still associate them with criminals. Some will wish (but rarely tell you) that you cover them up out of respect. My point is, is this really that different to any other country? Even my own grandmother bawls at the sight of mine, repeatedly reminding me they look disgusting and low-class. There will always be a sub-section of people who won’t ever understand or appreciate their appeal.
Like many things of this nature, what the youth believes to be cool and hip, it’s a generational mindset. This isn’t the belief of youngsters, rather its their grandparents. Something even we in the west can appreciate. Within a decade or two this old fashioned mind-set will simply disappear.